Men’s Shirts Issues Guide: Would I Buy It Again After 3 Months? Yes, But With One Big Catch

The rain came down hard, soaked through my collar in ten seconds flat. That’s when I started this whole stupid men’s shirts issues guide mess.

YES. I would buy it again. NO question. If you have one specific problem. That’s the catch. Stiff collars that curl up after one wash? I was about to throw every shirt in the trash. Then I tried what I’m about to tell you. But let me back up.

First problem with this men’s shirts issues guide idea

The collar. That’s the thing. I bought a shirt from a mid-range store, not cheap not fancy, and the collar stayed flat. BUTTONS were solid. Sleeves not too short. I thought I Last thing. found a fix. NOPE. After three washes the collar started curling again. What’s the point? You pay more and still get the same garbage? That frustrated me. REAL BAD. The cheap one failed me in one specific way I didn’t expect, so I upgraded. That cheap shirt had a button pop off after two wears. Plastic button. Felt like a toy. The mid-range one at least had thick stitching. But the collar? Same problem.

SO HERE’S THE THING. I tried ironing. I tried starch. I tried that spray stuff my wife left in the laundry room. Nothing. The collar still looked like a dead snake after a few hours. Now I’m not a fancy guy. I wear flannel most days. But I got fed up.

The scenario where my answer flips completely

If you have a button-down shirt with a fused collar? DON’T BUY IT. Fused collars are glued together. They curl up. They bubble. They look terrible. The specific alternative I tried was a shirt with a sewn-in collar. Cost a little more. But the collar stayed flat even after I forgot it in the dryer. That’s the scenario where I went from NO to YES. One shirt, one fabric, one construction method. Fused vs sewn. That’s the whole damn difference.

One thing that surprised me about men’s shirts issues guide

Anyway. The buttons. I always thought metal buttons were better. NO. They tarnish. They scratch. The cheap plastic ones break. But the best ones are actually mother of pearl? I thought that was some fancy nonsense but they don’t break and don’t tarnish. I couldn’t care less about fashion but I care about a button staying on. That surprised me. I still don’t understand why shirt makers don’t just use those for all shirts. Must be cost. Everything’s about cost.

One thing that frustrated me the most

The sleeve placket. The little flap on the cuff. You know what I mean? On cheap shirts, that flap doesn’t close all the way on the left side. I measured it. Off by a quarter inch. Not a big deal until you roll up your sleeves and the flap hangs out like a tongue. Drives me crazy. I bought three different types of shirts specifically to test this. Each had one dealbreaker. The cheap one had the bad placket. The mid-range had the fused collar. The expensive one? Too heavy. Felt like wearing a winter coat in summer. Sorry, I’m not paying premium price for something I can’t wear half the year.

Burst of anger then back to neutral

I HATE BATTERIES. What does this have to do with shirts? Nothing. But I saw some “smart” shirt that tracks your posture. WHAT A JOKE. If your shirt is that high-tech, you’re not wearing it twice. Anyway. Back to the guide.

The length of the shirt tail. Another issue. Shirts that are too short come untucked when you lift your arms. I don’t need my belly showing. I’m a construction worker, not a model. My simple fix: buy shirts with a “long tail” or “tuckable” cut. It’s not a feature they advertise. You have to read the fine print. That’s my actionable tip: check the tail length before you buy. Measure from your shoulder to below your belt. Add two inches. That’s the minimum.

Checklist for buyers from my men’s shirts issues guide

• Collar type: fused = avoid. Sewn-in = good. Pinch the collar. If it feels stiff like cardboard, fused.
• Sleeve placket: button it button it unbutton it. Does the flap lie flat? If not, skip it.
• Tail length: put the shirt on. Raise both arms overhead. If your belt shows, too short.
• Button material: plastic = fragile. mother of pearl = durable. metal = scratches.

The real difference nobody talks about

Fabric weight. I bought one shirt that felt thin like a bedsheet. Another felt thick like a tent. The thin one wrinkled before I left the house. The thick one was too hot. The mid-range one hit the sweet spot. Not too thin, not too thick. No clue the grams per square meter. Don’t care. I just know if I can hold it up to the light and see through it, it’s too thin. That’s my test. Works every time.

I still don’t understand why makers don’t put a small tag with the collar construction. It would save me hours. I guess they want me to buy the cheap ones, get frustrated, then buy the expensive ones. But I figured out the mid-range is fine if you check those four things. The collar was the biggest surprise. That’s what flipped my answer from NO to YES. But only for sewn-in collars.

So now you decide. You want a shirt that lasts? Get a mid-range with sewn collar, mother of pearl buttons, long tail, and check the placket. Don’t pay extra for a brand name. Don’t go cheap either. The cheap one will fail you. I learned that the hard way. I still have two cheap shirts that I never wear. Maybe I should donate them. But then again, maybe next time I’ll find a shirt that doesn’t curl, doesn’t pop buttons, doesn’t cost a fortune. Maybe that doesn’t exist. Maybe I’ll just keep wearing flannel and stop worrying about collars.

One last thing. The rain that started all this? It stopped four hours later. My shirt was still wet.

#Ad / Paid Link: The following links are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.