Why I Returned my gaming controller alternative (And What I Got Instead)

why the RGB on my gaming controller alternative is the feature I never use but everyone hypes
After months of travel, the RGB lighting on my gaming controller alternative turned out to be a useless gimmick for me. Here’s why you might skip it too.

The hotel room was too small for my laptop and coffee cup. I unpacked my gaming controller alternative, plugged it in, and the thing lit up like a mini disco. I never use the RGB lighting. Everyone raves about customizable colors, synchronized effects, “immersion” — but in a cramped airport lounge or a dim hotel room, all it does is throw weird blue light on my screen and drain battery. I bought the version with RGB because the reviews said it’s “essential for the full experience.” It’s not. It’s a gimmick that made the controller thicker, heavier, and more fragile in my bag.

why I’m skeptical of RGB on my gaming controller alternative

When I first unboxed it, I thought the rainbow swirl would be cool for late-night gaming sessions. Spoiler: it isn’t. The first time I tried playing in bed while my partner slept, the blinking lights kept catching their eye and I had to cover the controller with a shirt. That’s ridiculous. I paid extra for a feature that actively makes the product worse in the primary use case I bought it for — portable gaming in shared spaces. The simpler controller I used before, a basic wired one without any LEDs, was lighter, cheaper, and never bothered anyone. I honestly compared the two in a four-hour flight layover: the RGB one was awkward to angle away from me, and the battery died an hour earlier than expected. The cheap one just worked.

One specific scenario where the RGB absolutely did not matter: I was grinding through a dungeon in a dark corner of a hostel common room, and the lights from my controller were so distracting that I kept missing cue prompts. I turned them off in the software — only to find that the software app itself was bloated and kept crashing. So I just left the controller unlit from that day onward. What’s the point of a feature you can’t reliably disable? Now I have a controller that’s bulkier than it needs to be, with a pointless LED strip that adds nothing to my experience.

the one thing that surprised me about this controller

Despite my hatred for the RGB, the physical build quality actually impressed me. The thumbsticks are surprisingly grippy, the D-pad clicks with a satisfying tactile feedback, and the shoulder buttons don’t feel mushy after six months of tossing it into my backpack with cables and chargers. That’s the part I didn’t expect. I assumed a travel-focused controller would feel cheap, but the plastic has held up well — no creaking, no loose panels. The buttons are quiet enough that I can play in a quiet hotel room without waking up the neighbors, which is more than I can say for my older full-sized controller.

But here’s the frustration: the flap that covers the USB dongle storage doesn’t close all the way on the left side. Every time I pull the controller out of my bag, that little rubber door is half-open, letting dirt and lint accumulate inside. I’ve tried pressing it back into place, but it just pops out again. That’s a design flaw that has nothing to do with RGB, and it bothers me more than the lights ever did. I have to wrap a rubber band around the controller to keep the flap shut, which defeats the purpose of a sleek portable device.

one thing I still don’t understand about my gaming controller alternative

Why do manufacturers put RGB on a travel controller? Travel implies constraints: small bags, shared spaces, limited battery. RGB adds weight, draws power, and creates a social inconvenience. I can’t think of a single scenario in a hotel room, airplane seat, or coffee shop where I would want my controller to glow hot pink. Maybe for a LAN party with friends? But then you’re not traveling, you’re holding a small gathering at home. I genuinely don’t get the marketing logic. If the feature were a gimmick that I could ignore without penalty, fine — but it makes the controller larger and more expensive for no benefit to my use case.

Funny story. Now here’s the actionable advice I wish someone had given me before I bought my gaming controller alternative: make a checklist before you buy any travel-friendly controller. Here’s what to check:

• Battery type: removable AAs are easier to swap on the go than built-in rechargeable that might die mid-flight.
• Button noise: clicky switches annoy seat neighbors; look for quiet membrane or low-profile tactile.
• Stowable dongle: a dedicated compartment with a proper latch is non-negotiable for portability.
• Weight and profile: under 200 grams and flat enough to slide into a laptop sleeve?
• Lighting options: can you permanently disable all lights without software? If not, skip the RGB version.

For my specific use case — gaming in airport terminals and hotel beds — the simpler controller without RGB would have been a better choice. It’s lighter, cheaper, and wouldn’t have that stupid flap that keeps popping open. I overpaid for the premium version because everyone said RGB was “essential,” but the only thing it added was annoyance.

who should actually care about the RGB on my gaming controller alternative

You know who might actually use RGB on a travel controller? A streamer who does impromptu mobile broadcasts in well-lit hotel rooms, or someone who plays in a dedicated gaming café where aesthetics matter. Maybe if you’re a teenager who doesn’t share a room with anyone and loves flashy gear, the colors add fun. But for most travelers, it’s dead weight. If you value compactness, low profile, and minimal distraction, get the version without lights. I can’t recommend the RGB variant for anyone who games in public, shared, or dim spaces. The extra cost buys you nothing but a charging hassle.

I’m still using this controller because the build quality is solid, but every time I see that little rubber flap pop open, I think about the simpler alternative that’s sitting in a drawer at home, waiting to be packed. Maybe I’ll switch back. Or maybe I’ll find a travel controller that gets all the practical parts right — and leaves the RGB at home.

#Ad / Paid Link: The following links are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.